Products - Featured

Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Blondies

$6.00
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Ginger

$6.00
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Peppermint Patties

$6.00
Sale!

Hallie's Fudge turtlealley | Chocolate Fudge

$3.75
Sale!

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies turtlealley | Swedish Fish

$1.35
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Truffles turtlealley | The Hugo (Raspberry Truffle)

$6.00
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Uptown Payday

$6.00
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Needhams

$6.00
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Caramallo

$6.00

Highly Rated Products

Sale!

Latest Creations

Latest Creations turtlealley | Caramel Pretzel Bites

$6.00
Sale!

Caramels and Toffee

Caramels and Toffee turtlealley | Chocolate Covered Caramels

$6.00
Sale!

turtlealley | Commemorative T-Shirts

$7.50
Sale!

Clusters and Barks

Clusters and Barks turtlealley | Plain Bark

$6.00
Sale!

Clusters and Barks

Clusters and Barks turtlealley | Cranberry Bark

$6.00
Sale!

Clusters and Barks

Clusters and Barks turtlealley | Pecan Clusters

$6.00
Sale!

Caramels and Toffee

Caramels and Toffee turtlealley | Caramel Pareils

$6.00
Sale!

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Seasonal Novelties

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Seasonal Novelties turtlealley | Espresso Beans

$1.48
Sale!

Caramels and Toffee

Caramels and Toffee turtlealley | Fleur de Sel Caramels

$6.00
Sale!

Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut Butter Cups turtlealley | Spicy Peanut Butter Cup

$6.00
Sale!

Caramels and Toffee

Caramels and Toffee turtlealley | Buttercrunch

$6.00
Sale!

turtlealley | Good Shit Shirts

$5.98

Bestselling Products

Sale!

turtlealley | Ice Pack

$0.58

turtlealley|Ice Pack

SKU: 32681204908116 Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Peanut Butter Cups turtlealley | Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

$6.00

Peanut Butter Cups turtlealley|Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

SKU: DPBC-.5lb Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Hot Pops

$4.05

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley|Hot Pops

SKU: 34831296462893 Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Chocolate Covered Marshmallows

$6.00

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley|Chocolate Covered Marshmallows

SKU: SMALLO-.5lb-M Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies turtlealley | Sour Watermelon

$2.70

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies turtlealley|Sour Watermelon

SKU: 32519015530580 Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies turtlealley | Jelly Bellies

$4.05

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies turtlealley|Jelly Bellies

SKU: 32519016382548 Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Caramel Apples turtlealley | Turtle Apple - LOCAL PICKUP ONLY

$4.78

Caramel Apples turtlealley|Turtle Apple - LOCAL PICKUP ONLY

SKU: 34885580423213 Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Caramels and Toffee turtlealley | Alder Smoked Caramel

$6.00

Caramels and Toffee turtlealley|Alder Smoked Caramel

SKU: 34873147359277 Categories:
Read more
Sale!

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Seasonal Novelties

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Seasonal Novelties turtlealley | Reeds Rolls/Sour Cherry Rolls - Local Pickup Only

$0.58
Sale!

Clusters and Barks

Clusters and Barks turtlealley | Almond Bark

$6.00
Sale!

Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut Butter Cups turtlealley | White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

$6.00
Sale!

Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut Butter Cups turtlealley | The King

$6.00
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Cherries

$5.38
Sale!

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies

Gummies, Fruit Slices, Sour Patch, Jelly Bellies turtlealley | Fruit Slices

$2.10
Sale!

Caramel Apples

Caramel Apples turtlealley | Pecan Caramel Apple - LOCAL PICKUP ONLY

$4.48
Sale!

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al

Hand-Dipped Treats, et al turtlealley | Non Pareils

$6.00